Experience the fullness of the Christian Faith

Troubling Spirituality

Home
>>
Blog
>>
Troubling Spirituality
Fr. Geoff Harvey
February 2, 2007 11:39 AM

Spirituality by Frederica Mathewes-Green

 

Life in Christ.

I don't like the category "spirituality." It sounds so external. It sounds so *optional*. It isn't a concept I find in the first millennium, or anywhere in Eastern Christianity. As far as I can tell, what people today mean by "spirituality" is what St. Paul meant by "life in Christ."

 

Partakers of Divine Nature

This is a transformation that every Christian is supposed to be experiencing, because we are all "partakers of the divine nature" (2 Peter 1:4). As we partake of the life of Christ and discipline ourselves, seeking to assimilate that life, it affects both our souls and bodies. His light spreads within us like fire spreading through a lump of coal, and so we become Christ-bearers to the world. This is such an essential, foundational element of life in Christ that to extract it and label it seems to deaden it.

 

Participating in the light of the One Christ, but uniquely

Early Christians did not talk about "spirituality," much less varieties of spirituality, appropriate to this or that kind of personality, or ethnic background, or gender. Not only is that unhelpful, I don't think it's even possible to set up such divisions. Each one of us is participating in the light of the One Christ, so in one sense "spirituality" is exactly the same for everyone, because Christ is one. But each one of us is the only human being God ever made who is exactly us, so we will radiate that light back out again just a bit differently than any other saint.

 

Spirituality shopping

So although the unity of Christ means there is only one possible "spirituality," in another sense there are as many different "spiritualities" as the billions of people who live and who have lived. But an in-between that imagines that there are different styles appropriate to this or that sub-group, speaks of nothing so much as our culture's reflexive love of shopping.

 

Narcissism danger

The thing about contemporary "spirituality" that annoys me the most is its capacity for narcissism. Focusing on spirituality instead of on the Lord makes you stop halfway down the hallway and think about yourself. That obviously delays your progress. It can be a temptation to consumerism - "Gee, centering prayer didn't work, I think I'll try Ignatian meditation." And it can be a temptation to self-adornment, by suggesting that being spiritual makes you superior to other people, makes you more "interesting" or "deep." What appears to be very intentional involvement with spiritual things, can actually be simply the taking up a new beauty regimen.

 

The devil again.

We can say, as in Christ's parable of the wheat and tares, "An enemy has done this." It is a strategy of the Evil One to take a good impulse and twist it backward into self-regard.

 

Seek the Lord Jesus Christ.

The term "spirituality" is troublesome because it reifies something that ought to go unnoticed. When you start taking an exaggerated interest in your breathing is when your breathing starts going wrong. Our sole focus should be on the compelling beauty of our Lord, and what moves us forward is only our desire for him. So my advice is: don't seek an improved spirituality, or even a better prayer life. Just seek the Lord Jesus Christ, and keep your eyes on him.

 

Blog

Faith Beyond Boundaries
Fr. Nicholas Frazer
Fr. Nicholas Frazer
July 6, 2025 11:30 AM
In this moving sermon, Fr. Nicholas explores the profound faith of a Roman centurion, highlighting themes of humility, compassion, and intercession. Through the story, he challenges us to look beyond inherited religion and live our faith actively.
The Power of Faith and Commitment
Fr. Geoff Harvey
Fr. Geoff Harvey
June 29, 2025 11:30 AM
Fr. Geoff reflects on the courage and faith of the Patriarch in Syria, the confession of St. Peter, and the commitment of St. Paul. He shares the remarkable life of Metropolitan Anthony Bloom, urging us to consider what we are ready to live or die for. Fr. Geoff's message challenges us to find God within ourselves and live a life dedicated to His glory.
More...
Get involved by visiting our Facebook Page
Follow us on X.
Follow us on Instagram
@TheGoodShepherdOrthodoxChurch
Sign up to receive a regular email newsletter from Fr. Geoff.